Is It Two Equal but Opposing Points of View? Or Insanity Versus Honesty? (UPDATED)

In the red corner, wearing a knee brace and smiley-face briefs, we have Marshall Art opining on Al Gore's Nobel win.

In the blue corner, wearing a Botany 500 ensemble with a smashing Harvard tie, we have New York Times columnist Bob Herbert.

Read each, and judge for yourselves.

UPDATE: Links fixed. Thanks for letting me know, Jim. I hate when that happens.