It is more than a little synchronistic that I saw this article at TPM on the same day I had decided to do a little post on hell. I continue to find it amusing that the best these folks can come up with in their visions of eternal damnation is rooted in an early Renaissance poem. Not only are they unbiblical, they are unoriginal as well.
Most takes on hell - in literature, music, and the graphic arts - rely on Dante's poem as a guide. To think that the worst anyone can imagine is to be physically tortured by fire for all eternity shows a lack of understanding about what hell actually is. Hell is nothing more or less than complete and utter separation from God. Not the kind of separation we experience in this life, with its pain, temptation, more than occasional horrors, and the inevitability of our own deaths. It is a separation that leaves a hole that can never be filled. One may still be aware of God's existence; yet one will be forever cut off from that avenue of assistance.
As a Christian, I cannot imagine a torment more horrible than that. To exist knowing that one will never again be in any kind of communion with God is far more horrible than having demons burn me with pokers, or sinking in a vat filled with human excrement, or even rolling a boulder up a hill only to have it roll down again just as I reach the summit.
The best visual representations of this idea, to my mind, are videos by the heavy metal band Tool. These little animated explorations of the bizarre and strange offer, to me, a glimpse of what it would be like to exist in a place without God's presence. Creatures that cannot exist roving about. A place where the relationship between cause and effect does not exist. Most of all, these videos portray an aloneness that is irredeemable. The videos always strike me as horrific precisely because the little characters seem unable to access others when needed. It is through others that we confirm the basic rationality of our existence. It is with others that we console ourselves at our darkest moments. It is by others that our understanding of the world is confirmed. In an existence without any access to others there is no way to confirm our suspicions about the world. In hell, there is no sympathy, no fellow-feeling, no others that can agree with us, confirm our suspicions that what is around us makes no sense, or might make some sense. It is an existence without rules, without sense, without any escape whatsoever.
The kinds of "scary" offered up by fundamentalists and others just don't cut it for me. If Randall Terry showed up somewhere near me, I'd just laugh at this kind of thing. I can imagine something far more horrible, especially for people like Randall Terry who are willing to kill in the name of life - that's hell on earth.
The title is both question and description. Still trying to figure it out as we go. With some help, I might get something right.
Thursday, October 29, 2009
Wednesday, October 28, 2009
Vampires
With the gothic revival, Twilight. The Vampire Diaries, and all the rest of this hokum, it is easy to forget that vampires aren't exactly Euro-trash in white pancake.
My daughter is obsessed with Twilight, as are many tweens and young teens. Perhaps it's the Sturm und Drang of the love affair in question (I told Moriah that it was just Romeo and Juliet with vampires, and that the original was better because it had sword fights). Perhaps it's the allure of being tempted to bad in a good cause. The appeal, whatever it may be, is lost on me; perhaps I have no more romance in my soul, but the thought of running down deer rather than people just doesn't strike me as, I don't know, cool. Hasn't anyone told the kids who read this that part of the allure of vampires is turning other people in to vampires?
My daughter's obsession worried me enough this past summer I offered, as an alternative, Stephen King's delightfully scary, pulpy 'Salem's Lot as an alternative, and far more traditional, take on the vampire myth. In Barlow, we have the vampire as an incarnation of evil, even killing a child as a sacrifice to the Devil early on in the book. The most frightening moment in the book, for me, has always been the scenes of the young boy, lying in bed, seeing the vampire outside his bedroom window, scrabbling at the window and begging to be let in. It was weeks before I opened the curtains in my bedroom, the first time I read that.
More to the point, even Stoker's original had enough of a sheen of the gothic romance about it to rob the myth of its more frightening aspects. The contemporary take on it - Interview With A Vampire crap, Twilight, the vampire-rock of Atreyu and other neo-Goth metal bands - renders the whole myth less than frightening. Yet, at its heart, the vampire legends concern themselves with an abomination, the antithesis of the Christian proclamation of the resurrection of the dead. Rather than a life of glory before the throne of God, vampires are condemned to endless hunger, unquenchable thirst for the blood of the living. There is nothing romantic about it; it is a surrender to the most basic instinct human beings have - hunger - for an unfulfillable promise (everlasting life and youth).
Which is not to say I am going to bar Moriah from seeing New Moon when it comes out next month. Nor am I going prevent her from being a vampire for Halloween. I just wish we had better pop-culture guides to this story of evil incarnate than currently exist.
My daughter is obsessed with Twilight, as are many tweens and young teens. Perhaps it's the Sturm und Drang of the love affair in question (I told Moriah that it was just Romeo and Juliet with vampires, and that the original was better because it had sword fights). Perhaps it's the allure of being tempted to bad in a good cause. The appeal, whatever it may be, is lost on me; perhaps I have no more romance in my soul, but the thought of running down deer rather than people just doesn't strike me as, I don't know, cool. Hasn't anyone told the kids who read this that part of the allure of vampires is turning other people in to vampires?
My daughter's obsession worried me enough this past summer I offered, as an alternative, Stephen King's delightfully scary, pulpy 'Salem's Lot as an alternative, and far more traditional, take on the vampire myth. In Barlow, we have the vampire as an incarnation of evil, even killing a child as a sacrifice to the Devil early on in the book. The most frightening moment in the book, for me, has always been the scenes of the young boy, lying in bed, seeing the vampire outside his bedroom window, scrabbling at the window and begging to be let in. It was weeks before I opened the curtains in my bedroom, the first time I read that.
More to the point, even Stoker's original had enough of a sheen of the gothic romance about it to rob the myth of its more frightening aspects. The contemporary take on it - Interview With A Vampire crap, Twilight, the vampire-rock of Atreyu and other neo-Goth metal bands - renders the whole myth less than frightening. Yet, at its heart, the vampire legends concern themselves with an abomination, the antithesis of the Christian proclamation of the resurrection of the dead. Rather than a life of glory before the throne of God, vampires are condemned to endless hunger, unquenchable thirst for the blood of the living. There is nothing romantic about it; it is a surrender to the most basic instinct human beings have - hunger - for an unfulfillable promise (everlasting life and youth).
Which is not to say I am going to bar Moriah from seeing New Moon when it comes out next month. Nor am I going prevent her from being a vampire for Halloween. I just wish we had better pop-culture guides to this story of evil incarnate than currently exist.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009
I'm Glad There's Not A Brick Wall Around, Because I Would Beat My Head Against It
Is it at all possible for people to write and talk about science without using the word belief? One does not "believe" in Newton's law of universal gravitation, or Mendelian genetics, or quantum mechanics. These are general descriptions of actual physical phenomena, open to any person's understanding. While not "true" in any philosophical sense, they are good for getting on with as descriptions of the way the universe seems to operate, at least as we understand it thus far. Belief, in any manner fashion or form, doesn't enter the picture.
I am so tired of people talking about "believing in" evolution, with climate change now added like an aperitif of stupid. One neither believes nor doesn't believe in the science behind the theory of global warming. One can read any of the hundreds of scientific papers and monographs on the subject, consider the methodology, the inherent limitations, and conclusions involved, and accept or not accept it. If anyone says, "I believe in evolution," that person isn't talking about a scientific theory of which I am aware. Or, perhaps, they are dumb enough to think one can "believe" the sun is a big ball of hydrogen without any reference to whether or not it actually is a big ball of hydrogen.
Isn't it possible to talk about science in a way that is clear? Pretty please with sugar on top?
I am so tired of people talking about "believing in" evolution, with climate change now added like an aperitif of stupid. One neither believes nor doesn't believe in the science behind the theory of global warming. One can read any of the hundreds of scientific papers and monographs on the subject, consider the methodology, the inherent limitations, and conclusions involved, and accept or not accept it. If anyone says, "I believe in evolution," that person isn't talking about a scientific theory of which I am aware. Or, perhaps, they are dumb enough to think one can "believe" the sun is a big ball of hydrogen without any reference to whether or not it actually is a big ball of hydrogen.
Isn't it possible to talk about science in a way that is clear? Pretty please with sugar on top?
Brad Hirschfield Is Stupid
Evidence.
For the eleventy-billionth time, hate crimes do not punish thought, speech, or belief. They punish acts. How is it possible, considering we as a nation have been discussing the issue for roughly a decade now, this isn't clear? Is Rabbi Hirschfield that stupid?
Or is he deliberately misrepresenting what hate crimes are?
I suppose offering the choice is disingenuous of me; he could be both. . .
Punishing individuals for what they believe and not what they have done is a scary precedent which avoids the real cultural challenges we face and potentially devalues the significance of crimes not rising to the level of a hate crime.
For the eleventy-billionth time, hate crimes do not punish thought, speech, or belief. They punish acts. How is it possible, considering we as a nation have been discussing the issue for roughly a decade now, this isn't clear? Is Rabbi Hirschfield that stupid?
Or is he deliberately misrepresenting what hate crimes are?
I suppose offering the choice is disingenuous of me; he could be both. . .
Possession
I realized yesterday that, with Halloween coming, I had written a post entitled "Evil". I decided, more out of a sense of fun than anything else, to do some other similarly themes kinds of things until this Saturday.
I am old enough to remember when The Exorcist was scary. To be honest, the first time I saw it, some (although not all) of the scenes really scared the shit out of me. The sounds from the attic early on, especially; my parents' house has a big attic and while it was never really scary, forever after I would wonder whether I would hear sounds portending something horrible from up above.
My view of the movie, and its subject matter, has changed drastically over time. I guess I really didn't think much about the topic - demon possession - until I was a bit older. After studying theology and all, though, I have to ask a question: Why would they bother? Furthermore, I have to wonder about the Roman Catholic view of exorcism, at least as presented in the movie.
It seems to me that declaring the name of Christ would be enough to banish the demon back to whatever circle of hell it usually occupies. Or are demons more powerful than the Second Person of the Trinity?
While I'm at it, why are demons, and evil things in general, very often offered up to audiences as erudite, refined, well-educated, just kind of short-tempered with weak stomachs and silly ideas about what might be considered blasphemous (Linda Blair projective vomiting pea soup on the priest isn't scary, it's just kind of gross; the whole masturbating with a crucifix is actually disturbing, although not in a theological sense)? Does that mean that well-mannered, educated humans are actually demons in disguise? Stephen King pulled the same trick in the novel Salem's Lot (the original TV movie version had the vampire Barlow more a Nosferatu-type of creature, rather than dandyfied Euro-trash like the book). Just because a demon, or a vampire, or whatever evil creature we may be referencing, has been alive a long time doesn't mean it is intelligent. Isn't it possible there are demons who are as stupid as stumps, and that stupidity is reflected in their speech?
In all, while it has provided fodder for one moderately scary movie, as a possible paranormal event, I just don't accept the idea that there are metaphysical creatures from hell just itching to "take over" us human beings. Considering the horrors that we human beings routinely visit upon one another without the direct intervention of such alleged creatures or events, I for one would want to ask a person who claims to be possessed, "Wasn't Rwanda evil enough for you?"
I am old enough to remember when The Exorcist was scary. To be honest, the first time I saw it, some (although not all) of the scenes really scared the shit out of me. The sounds from the attic early on, especially; my parents' house has a big attic and while it was never really scary, forever after I would wonder whether I would hear sounds portending something horrible from up above.
My view of the movie, and its subject matter, has changed drastically over time. I guess I really didn't think much about the topic - demon possession - until I was a bit older. After studying theology and all, though, I have to ask a question: Why would they bother? Furthermore, I have to wonder about the Roman Catholic view of exorcism, at least as presented in the movie.
It seems to me that declaring the name of Christ would be enough to banish the demon back to whatever circle of hell it usually occupies. Or are demons more powerful than the Second Person of the Trinity?
While I'm at it, why are demons, and evil things in general, very often offered up to audiences as erudite, refined, well-educated, just kind of short-tempered with weak stomachs and silly ideas about what might be considered blasphemous (Linda Blair projective vomiting pea soup on the priest isn't scary, it's just kind of gross; the whole masturbating with a crucifix is actually disturbing, although not in a theological sense)? Does that mean that well-mannered, educated humans are actually demons in disguise? Stephen King pulled the same trick in the novel Salem's Lot (the original TV movie version had the vampire Barlow more a Nosferatu-type of creature, rather than dandyfied Euro-trash like the book). Just because a demon, or a vampire, or whatever evil creature we may be referencing, has been alive a long time doesn't mean it is intelligent. Isn't it possible there are demons who are as stupid as stumps, and that stupidity is reflected in their speech?
In all, while it has provided fodder for one moderately scary movie, as a possible paranormal event, I just don't accept the idea that there are metaphysical creatures from hell just itching to "take over" us human beings. Considering the horrors that we human beings routinely visit upon one another without the direct intervention of such alleged creatures or events, I for one would want to ask a person who claims to be possessed, "Wasn't Rwanda evil enough for you?"
Monday, October 26, 2009
Music For Your Monday
In honor of the upcoming festivities. . .
"Black Sabbath" was written, in part, from an alleged experience bass player Terry "Geezer" Butler had. Also, it was written to set out a template for future songs by the band, which took its name from a Vincent Price movie. Butler was a fan of horror films, and wanted to separate out the music the band was playing, originally a bluesy kind of thing (at the time, the band was still known as Earth, which created booking issues, cause there was a British hippy-dippy pop band by the same name with a minor UK hit). Coming from the industrial working class, their experiences were not all happy-smiley- let's all drop acid and make love not war. While they would expand their musical horizons over the decade, this song still works pretty well (a warning - Ozzy's intro is NSFW)
The first round of death metal bands to emerge in Europe - Mercyful Fate and Venom being among the better ones - were over the top in terms of their dress and general presentation. Metallica drew a lot of early inspiration from Venom, toured with them for quite a while, but didn't copy their studs-for-Satan personas. They aren't to be taken seriously, really, beyond being a good band that managed to create a lot of press by being outrageous. This song, "Welcome to Hell", is one of their better ones.
Rob Zombie has turned more and more to film direction, with his recasting of the Halloween franchise not just different from the original, but quite good in and for themselves. His fascination with schlocky horror kitsch is evident in his music as well. I think "Living Dead Girl" is one of his better songs; a few years ago, I offered it as part of a soundtrack for a community theater production of "Dracula". That and "Bela Lugosi's Dead", of course. . .
"Black Sabbath" was written, in part, from an alleged experience bass player Terry "Geezer" Butler had. Also, it was written to set out a template for future songs by the band, which took its name from a Vincent Price movie. Butler was a fan of horror films, and wanted to separate out the music the band was playing, originally a bluesy kind of thing (at the time, the band was still known as Earth, which created booking issues, cause there was a British hippy-dippy pop band by the same name with a minor UK hit). Coming from the industrial working class, their experiences were not all happy-smiley- let's all drop acid and make love not war. While they would expand their musical horizons over the decade, this song still works pretty well (a warning - Ozzy's intro is NSFW)
The first round of death metal bands to emerge in Europe - Mercyful Fate and Venom being among the better ones - were over the top in terms of their dress and general presentation. Metallica drew a lot of early inspiration from Venom, toured with them for quite a while, but didn't copy their studs-for-Satan personas. They aren't to be taken seriously, really, beyond being a good band that managed to create a lot of press by being outrageous. This song, "Welcome to Hell", is one of their better ones.
Rob Zombie has turned more and more to film direction, with his recasting of the Halloween franchise not just different from the original, but quite good in and for themselves. His fascination with schlocky horror kitsch is evident in his music as well. I think "Living Dead Girl" is one of his better songs; a few years ago, I offered it as part of a soundtrack for a community theater production of "Dracula". That and "Bela Lugosi's Dead", of course. . .
Evil
One of the sillier things one read and heard far too often in the wake of President George W. Bush's name-calling of the 9/11 hijackers as "evildoers" was that we liberals are incapable of seeing and calling out "evil". I am about to prove them wrong. Ahem.
It should be obvious to any but the most sociopathic brain that such a horrific act is evil.
Do evil acts, however, make the individuals who perform them morally vicious, and therefore outside our circle of concern and even love? Certainly, it is more than troubling that a group of teenagers would not only conceive of such an act, but actually carry it out. Keeping them away from others is best for all concerned, to be sure. Yet these practical, legal, matters don't address the question of whether or not they are evil.
Any thoughts? Anyone?
Michael owed 15-year-old Matthew Bent $40 for a video game, but hadn't paid up. So on Sunday, Bent tried to steal Michael's dad's bike as compensation. Micheal thwarted the theft, and his family called the cops. Bent was arrested.
But he was sent home after a brief stay in juvie. Michael skipped school Monday, fearing payback. Bent didn't go to school either.
Monday afternoon, Michael went over to the Lime Street Apartments to visit a friend. Bent just happened to be there as well. Michael was sitting by the pool when he was surrounded by five boys: Bent, Denver Colorado Jarvis, 15; his brother Jeremy Jarvis, 13; Steven Shelton, 15; and Jesus Mendez, 15.
They grabbed a bottle of rubbing alcohol they found and surrounded Michael. Bent called him a rat. Michael tried to leave but couldn't. Bent ordered the rubbing alcohol poured on Michael. Denver Jarvis doused him with the fluid, then Mendez set him on fire.
It should be obvious to any but the most sociopathic brain that such a horrific act is evil.
Do evil acts, however, make the individuals who perform them morally vicious, and therefore outside our circle of concern and even love? Certainly, it is more than troubling that a group of teenagers would not only conceive of such an act, but actually carry it out. Keeping them away from others is best for all concerned, to be sure. Yet these practical, legal, matters don't address the question of whether or not they are evil.
Any thoughts? Anyone?
Pointless
Via Crooks and Liars, I stumbled across this little tid-bit of dumb. In all honesty, why do people even bother?
This is the kind of undergraduate-debate-society topic that resolves nothing, creates more tension and anxiety than it relieves, and offers little hope of real communication.
Had I been present, I might just have said something like, "God does not ask us to be good, God asks us to be faithful in love. Whatever flows from that is, by definition, good whether or not it conforms to whatever passes for morality." Since the whole issue begs far more questions than it settles, I can't really say I find it either meaningful or interesting.
But, then again, I'm a false teacher, so what do I know.
This is the kind of undergraduate-debate-society topic that resolves nothing, creates more tension and anxiety than it relieves, and offers little hope of real communication.
Had I been present, I might just have said something like, "God does not ask us to be good, God asks us to be faithful in love. Whatever flows from that is, by definition, good whether or not it conforms to whatever passes for morality." Since the whole issue begs far more questions than it settles, I can't really say I find it either meaningful or interesting.
But, then again, I'm a false teacher, so what do I know.
Sunday, October 25, 2009
The Hazards Of Cheap Spiritual Enlightenment
I hadn't heard about the deaths. In fact, I have never heard of James Ray, and now that I have, I don't feel like my brain has expanded because of that information. Yet, to describe what happened in Sedona as part of a problem with "self-help", as Christine Whelan does, is to completely misunderstand what occurred. Is Ray criminally responsible for the deaths of two people in a sweat lodge in Arizona? Perhaps, although if he is found so guilty, that doesn't mean there is a problem with "self-help" per se.
The real problem is that, like most middle-class, moderately educated Americans, the folks who listened to Ray and paid him nearly $10,000 for the privilege of a weekend getaway had absolutely no idea what they were getting themselves into. My guess is neither did Ray. Ours is a society that, for the most part, is bereft of any spiritual understanding whatsoever. Far too many Americans view "religion" and "spirituality" as synonyms, life-commodities to be traded at will on the open market for a "best fit". Witness denomination-hopping as a kind of surface-level example of what I'm describing.
The desire for spiritual cleansing is understandable. Yet Ray, by providing at a high price the promise of some kind of fulfillment over a weekend, in all likelihood neither believing nor caring about the potential hazards involved, does not provide any spiritual cleansing at all. Before entering a sweat lodge, or venturing out on a vision quest, or going to Australia and attempting a "singing", it takes years of physical, psychological, and spiritual preparation. Ray is a snake-oil salesman who has been given a real cure for once; except, of course, he not only neither knows nor cares, he has no idea that some of the possible side-effects of this cure can be dangerous. For what were, in all likelihood well-fed, pampered, relatively physically inert groups of people to attempt a sweat lodge is not only physically dangerous; it courts spiritual dangers as well.
I wish I could recall where I read it, but the phrase, "Never fuck with the eternal", popped in to my head while I was reading this piece. Ray is an ignorant yahoo, looking to make a quick buck off the even more ignorant yahoos who think that a "spiritual experience" can be bought with something as easy and cheap as money. Sometimes, spiritual enlightenment comes with a very high price tag indeed. Anyone with even a modicum of understanding of the history of these and other rituals would have been able to tell Ray that he was standing with his toes dangling over an infinite drop, believing he could lead people over the abyss without any harm done.
The path that leads to a deeper spiritual awareness very often intersects the path that leads to death; without any understanding of the hazards involved, one can easily stray off the way. Indeed, sometimes even with that understanding, it happens, anyway. James Ray has no idea that he is offering not the chance to be a "Spiritual Warrior", but the chance to stare God in the eye and live. Few can really do that; those that have done it usually end up slightly crazy afterward (read Ezekiel if you think I'm kidding). In the battle between our fragile selves and the unending point that is both everything and nothing, beyond what we can imagine, most human beings wind up like other warriors before them - quite dead.
The real problem is that, like most middle-class, moderately educated Americans, the folks who listened to Ray and paid him nearly $10,000 for the privilege of a weekend getaway had absolutely no idea what they were getting themselves into. My guess is neither did Ray. Ours is a society that, for the most part, is bereft of any spiritual understanding whatsoever. Far too many Americans view "religion" and "spirituality" as synonyms, life-commodities to be traded at will on the open market for a "best fit". Witness denomination-hopping as a kind of surface-level example of what I'm describing.
The desire for spiritual cleansing is understandable. Yet Ray, by providing at a high price the promise of some kind of fulfillment over a weekend, in all likelihood neither believing nor caring about the potential hazards involved, does not provide any spiritual cleansing at all. Before entering a sweat lodge, or venturing out on a vision quest, or going to Australia and attempting a "singing", it takes years of physical, psychological, and spiritual preparation. Ray is a snake-oil salesman who has been given a real cure for once; except, of course, he not only neither knows nor cares, he has no idea that some of the possible side-effects of this cure can be dangerous. For what were, in all likelihood well-fed, pampered, relatively physically inert groups of people to attempt a sweat lodge is not only physically dangerous; it courts spiritual dangers as well.
I wish I could recall where I read it, but the phrase, "Never fuck with the eternal", popped in to my head while I was reading this piece. Ray is an ignorant yahoo, looking to make a quick buck off the even more ignorant yahoos who think that a "spiritual experience" can be bought with something as easy and cheap as money. Sometimes, spiritual enlightenment comes with a very high price tag indeed. Anyone with even a modicum of understanding of the history of these and other rituals would have been able to tell Ray that he was standing with his toes dangling over an infinite drop, believing he could lead people over the abyss without any harm done.
The path that leads to a deeper spiritual awareness very often intersects the path that leads to death; without any understanding of the hazards involved, one can easily stray off the way. Indeed, sometimes even with that understanding, it happens, anyway. James Ray has no idea that he is offering not the chance to be a "Spiritual Warrior", but the chance to stare God in the eye and live. Few can really do that; those that have done it usually end up slightly crazy afterward (read Ezekiel if you think I'm kidding). In the battle between our fragile selves and the unending point that is both everything and nothing, beyond what we can imagine, most human beings wind up like other warriors before them - quite dead.
Saturday, October 24, 2009
Saturday Rock Show
The fall of 1990, I listened to Sting's second solo CD over and over again. Don't ask me why. . .
Keeping It Real
I am re-reading Faking It: The Quest For Authenticity in Popular Music by Hugh Barker and Yuval Taylor. I am still impressed with the book, and am glad it was written. Yet, while they certainly push the reader to reconsider whether or not "authenticity" is a category worth considering when evaluating an artist, they never directly ask a question via their use of examples that would challenge their readers to question whether the word has any meaning at all.
The first chapter discusses the lives and careers of two artists - Kurt Cobain and Leadbelly - and the way the epithet "authentic" distorted the perception of their music, and in particular Cobain's view of himself as a public figure. The relationship between the two became fixed forever because Nirvana's last performance, on MTV's "Unplugged" series, was of the Leadbelly tune "Where Did You Sleep Last Night". This chapter illuminates all the problems and pitfalls inherent in using the category "authenticity" when approaching American popular music (and, by extension, the artists who perform it), yet it might have been just as illuminating to use another performer entirely - Britney Spears.
I have yet to read a serious music journalist who takes her or her music seriously. Yet, when one considers, in detail, what it is she does and how she does it, I have to wonder if the whole question of "authenticity" isn't one that, in the end, is only applied to those performers certain people prefer, and withheld from those whose music they do not like. Her music is danceable, as the best popular music has always been. Some of the songs, especially on her more recent recordings, deal with sexual themes, including masturbation and a menage-a-trois, yet sex has been at the heart of popular music styles for centuries. Her shows are elaborate productions, very often choreographed with her lip-synching rather than singing the songs. Do the words "Michael Jackson" mean anything? Her voice is limited both in tonal range and emotional reflection; Billie Holliday could barely sing more than an octave and even her happiest songs end up sounding quite melancholy because there was something about her voice that seemed to bring out the ache that always existed deep inside her. Her music has been popular, for the most part, with young teenagers, particularly girls. All I will say to this is "Elvis" and "The Beatles".
What I believe most people object to about Britney Spears is the deliberate packaging and production of "Britney Spears" as something more than just a performer. Yet Bob Dylan, The Rolling Stones, The Beatles, Elvis, Chuck Berry, Metallica - these performers are also packaged as "not just" performers. Really, though, that's all they are; musicians or groups of musicians of varying musical talent and ability (not the same thing at all) who play for our enjoyment (another word that deserves to be unpacked in book form).
So if Britney Spears is a big faker while U2 is the real deal, all I can ask is, "Why?"
The first chapter discusses the lives and careers of two artists - Kurt Cobain and Leadbelly - and the way the epithet "authentic" distorted the perception of their music, and in particular Cobain's view of himself as a public figure. The relationship between the two became fixed forever because Nirvana's last performance, on MTV's "Unplugged" series, was of the Leadbelly tune "Where Did You Sleep Last Night". This chapter illuminates all the problems and pitfalls inherent in using the category "authenticity" when approaching American popular music (and, by extension, the artists who perform it), yet it might have been just as illuminating to use another performer entirely - Britney Spears.
I have yet to read a serious music journalist who takes her or her music seriously. Yet, when one considers, in detail, what it is she does and how she does it, I have to wonder if the whole question of "authenticity" isn't one that, in the end, is only applied to those performers certain people prefer, and withheld from those whose music they do not like. Her music is danceable, as the best popular music has always been. Some of the songs, especially on her more recent recordings, deal with sexual themes, including masturbation and a menage-a-trois, yet sex has been at the heart of popular music styles for centuries. Her shows are elaborate productions, very often choreographed with her lip-synching rather than singing the songs. Do the words "Michael Jackson" mean anything? Her voice is limited both in tonal range and emotional reflection; Billie Holliday could barely sing more than an octave and even her happiest songs end up sounding quite melancholy because there was something about her voice that seemed to bring out the ache that always existed deep inside her. Her music has been popular, for the most part, with young teenagers, particularly girls. All I will say to this is "Elvis" and "The Beatles".
What I believe most people object to about Britney Spears is the deliberate packaging and production of "Britney Spears" as something more than just a performer. Yet Bob Dylan, The Rolling Stones, The Beatles, Elvis, Chuck Berry, Metallica - these performers are also packaged as "not just" performers. Really, though, that's all they are; musicians or groups of musicians of varying musical talent and ability (not the same thing at all) who play for our enjoyment (another word that deserves to be unpacked in book form).
So if Britney Spears is a big faker while U2 is the real deal, all I can ask is, "Why?"
Friday, October 23, 2009
I Don't Like Media Whores
While it is nice to see that a liberal member of Congress has a set of testicles and is not afraid to use them (politically), my guess is Rep. Alan Grayson is becoming a bit too enamored of all the attention he is getting. Like Newt Gingrich, Joe Lieberman, John McCain, Lindsey Graham, and a few others, saying all sorts of stuff that grabs the attention of journalists is a sure-fire way to raise your favorability ratings; yet, it also runs the risk of saying all sorts of stupid stuff that really is beside the point. What's worse, when you actually start to believe the stuff you're saying, it becomes embarrassing (Newt and Joe . . .).
My hope is Rep. Grayson learns that a well-timed bon mot is far better than just shouting all sorts of things so your name appears in the papers and you get invited on to cable chat shows.
My hope is Rep. Grayson learns that a well-timed bon mot is far better than just shouting all sorts of things so your name appears in the papers and you get invited on to cable chat shows.
BS
Of all the stories of the health insurance industry acting like dicks, this one makes my blood boil. It is, quite simply, indefensible.
I am quite sure that they feel no shame, they are in fact incapable of any emotion whatsoever. For the sake of all the Christina Turner's out there, we need a public option.
After being drugged and physically assaulted, Christina Turner woke up in a ditch. She feared that she had been sexually assualted and so she went on a PEP (post-exposure prophylaxis, to prevent an HIV infection) regimen of pills. However, what Christina did not realize is that the history of having taken those medications would raise too many flags and inhibit her ability to be insured in the future. She had a dreaded pre-existing condition.
I am quite sure that they feel no shame, they are in fact incapable of any emotion whatsoever. For the sake of all the Christina Turner's out there, we need a public option.
Thursday, October 22, 2009
Liberal Heresy
I'm a left-winger who works at Wal-Mart. As such, I think I have a pretty good idea what the company is like, how it is managed, and what working there is like. In her book Nickled and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, Barbara Ehrenreich revealed that she lied her way in to several jobs, including one as a Wal-Mart associate, and reported her findings. In a style reminiscent of Barbara Bush's at the Super Dome in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, Ehrenreich wrote disdainfully of having to zone underwear, of the perfidy of their anti-union orientation video, and on and on.
Wal-Mart is no more or less evil than any corporation. They manage to get all sorts of bad press because they are so large. Extremely risk-averse - trust me when I tell you they try to avoid anything that will cost them money - when bad things happen, they usually manage to make it far worse than it actually was.
As far as the zoning thing is concerned, yes it is mind-numbingly dull, as Ehrenreich suggests. On the other hand, would anyone reading this visit a store where it was impossible to shop because everything was cattywampus on the shelves and impossible to find? Does Ehrenreich think that a store stays neat and clean all on its own? Does she object to zoning because it is, hm, I don't know, manual labor?
Unlike most left-wingers, I have no objection to big box stores, to chain bookstores, or other large and variegated companies that provide all sorts of amenities to all sorts of people. I am not blind to their preference that their workforce not be unionized; I also happen to think that, should EFCA pass (which I predict it probably will), Target, Wal-Mart, ShopKo and other such places will be unionized within a few years. I am not blind to all sorts of things Wal-Mart does that I would prefer it wouldn't. On the other hand, I was not surprised by the "news" that Whole Foods is no better than Wal-Mart, precisely because it is a corporation in business to make money.
The disdain many left-wingers have for Wal-Mart is, I believe, rooted not in some principled stance in favor of an organized workforce, or better working conditions, because the conditions at Wal-Mart are, for the most part, no different than any other place of employment. Rather, I firmly believe, as evidenced by Ehrenreich's tone of hauteur at having to mix with the polloi as she zoned thongs, it is rooted in a class bias against working people and their lives. You see the bumper sticker that reads, "If you see this car at Wal-Mart, it has been stolen", and you have to celebrate such a huge love of the working class.
In short, while I have no problem with getting the word out when any corporation does something illegal, it would be nice to have a little perspective. Wal-Mart is a corporation, no different from Standard Oil, DuPont, or Whole Foods. The tension between the company and its desire to make a profit and the employees who have a desire for stable work at a decent wage will always exist. Don't make any company out to be either a hero or a villain, because, for the most part, it's just a corporation doing what it has to do.
Wal-Mart is no more or less evil than any corporation. They manage to get all sorts of bad press because they are so large. Extremely risk-averse - trust me when I tell you they try to avoid anything that will cost them money - when bad things happen, they usually manage to make it far worse than it actually was.
As far as the zoning thing is concerned, yes it is mind-numbingly dull, as Ehrenreich suggests. On the other hand, would anyone reading this visit a store where it was impossible to shop because everything was cattywampus on the shelves and impossible to find? Does Ehrenreich think that a store stays neat and clean all on its own? Does she object to zoning because it is, hm, I don't know, manual labor?
Unlike most left-wingers, I have no objection to big box stores, to chain bookstores, or other large and variegated companies that provide all sorts of amenities to all sorts of people. I am not blind to their preference that their workforce not be unionized; I also happen to think that, should EFCA pass (which I predict it probably will), Target, Wal-Mart, ShopKo and other such places will be unionized within a few years. I am not blind to all sorts of things Wal-Mart does that I would prefer it wouldn't. On the other hand, I was not surprised by the "news" that Whole Foods is no better than Wal-Mart, precisely because it is a corporation in business to make money.
The disdain many left-wingers have for Wal-Mart is, I believe, rooted not in some principled stance in favor of an organized workforce, or better working conditions, because the conditions at Wal-Mart are, for the most part, no different than any other place of employment. Rather, I firmly believe, as evidenced by Ehrenreich's tone of hauteur at having to mix with the polloi as she zoned thongs, it is rooted in a class bias against working people and their lives. You see the bumper sticker that reads, "If you see this car at Wal-Mart, it has been stolen", and you have to celebrate such a huge love of the working class.
In short, while I have no problem with getting the word out when any corporation does something illegal, it would be nice to have a little perspective. Wal-Mart is a corporation, no different from Standard Oil, DuPont, or Whole Foods. The tension between the company and its desire to make a profit and the employees who have a desire for stable work at a decent wage will always exist. Don't make any company out to be either a hero or a villain, because, for the most part, it's just a corporation doing what it has to do.
Please Don't Play "Toxic" Again!
If it was me, I'd ask them if they took requests.
OK, maybe being force-fed Pearl Jam should be outlawed by the UN . . .
Last year, a coalition of musicians, along with British human rights charity Reprieve, created an anti-torture initiative called “Zero db” that sought to end the use of music in torture. Now, a new coalition of international musicians, including Trent Reznor, R.E.M., Pearl Jam, Jackson Browne, Rage Against the Machine, Rosanne Cash, Billy Bragg and the Roots, is launching a new protest against the use of music used during torture and are joining the National Campaign to Close Guantanamo.
As part of their protest, the musicians are supporting an effort seeking the declassification of all secret government records pertaining to how music was used in interrogations.
OK, maybe being force-fed Pearl Jam should be outlawed by the UN . . .
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
Silence Is Not Consent
I have been quiet about the Louisiana JOP who refused to marry an interracial couple. This is not because I am shocked and saddened by this; nor is it because I think it relatively unimportant. On the contrary, I think this incident, which might seem small and insignificant to some, is hugely important. I guess I just don't want to follow the herd with various web-stories and all.
Yet, it has occurred to me that my silence on this matter might actually be interpreted as acquiescence. The reasons the JOP gave for refusing to marry this couple - out of "concern" for "the children" - actually makes me want to rage, because I know four intelligent, funny, gifted children without whom the world would be a little less special had this kind of thinking prevailed: my nephews and niece.
I recently got in to a bit of a pissing contest with someone whom I admire, like, and am grateful for. I know that he, too, is married to a lovely, talented woman and has lovely, talented children none of which would be true of this dork had been in charge.
The man's statement the other day that he didn't break any laws and didn't "prevent" them from getting married because he gave them information on another justice who would do it misses the point. As long as the basic legal qualifications for marriage were met by this couple, this man was obligated to perform the ceremony as long as it didn't interfere with his other duties as JOP.
The refusal to marry a couple based solely on race is not a minor glitch, but an affront not just to the constitution and our laws, but to common decency. What's worse, the stated reasons are as small-minded and bigoted as the act itself; as has been pointed out a bit too much, our President is the result of a mixed marriage, as is the world's richest pro golfer. Besides these examples, there are millions of young people who are alive and smart and funny and tender and have loving homes with parents of different races. The arbitrary, illegal, and bigoted decision to refuse to marry this couple is an insult to all those families as well, betraying an ignorance of the reality that our wonderfully diverse land is filled with all sorts of success stories, all sorts of families and people, who lead happy, productive lives without necessarily following the rules of what used to be considered acceptable.
I guess I was feeling a bit bad that I hadn't made it clear how angry and sad I was when I heard about this. I did not want in any manner, fashion, or form, for my silence on this event to be considered consent.
Offered with apologies.
Yet, it has occurred to me that my silence on this matter might actually be interpreted as acquiescence. The reasons the JOP gave for refusing to marry this couple - out of "concern" for "the children" - actually makes me want to rage, because I know four intelligent, funny, gifted children without whom the world would be a little less special had this kind of thinking prevailed: my nephews and niece.
I recently got in to a bit of a pissing contest with someone whom I admire, like, and am grateful for. I know that he, too, is married to a lovely, talented woman and has lovely, talented children none of which would be true of this dork had been in charge.
The man's statement the other day that he didn't break any laws and didn't "prevent" them from getting married because he gave them information on another justice who would do it misses the point. As long as the basic legal qualifications for marriage were met by this couple, this man was obligated to perform the ceremony as long as it didn't interfere with his other duties as JOP.
The refusal to marry a couple based solely on race is not a minor glitch, but an affront not just to the constitution and our laws, but to common decency. What's worse, the stated reasons are as small-minded and bigoted as the act itself; as has been pointed out a bit too much, our President is the result of a mixed marriage, as is the world's richest pro golfer. Besides these examples, there are millions of young people who are alive and smart and funny and tender and have loving homes with parents of different races. The arbitrary, illegal, and bigoted decision to refuse to marry this couple is an insult to all those families as well, betraying an ignorance of the reality that our wonderfully diverse land is filled with all sorts of success stories, all sorts of families and people, who lead happy, productive lives without necessarily following the rules of what used to be considered acceptable.
I guess I was feeling a bit bad that I hadn't made it clear how angry and sad I was when I heard about this. I did not want in any manner, fashion, or form, for my silence on this event to be considered consent.
Offered with apologies.
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
I Feel Better And Better About My Decision
My conscience is even more clear today concerning my decision not to enter the stupid WaPo pundit contest after reading this.
Pat Buchanan's Mourning
It shouldn't surprise anyone that Pat Buchanan has written a sad, mournful column about the current state of America. It shouldn't surprise anyone that his mourning is mostly about the fact that "white people" feel their country has been stolen from them.
In fact, the only thing about Buchanan's column that is surprising is the absence of code, the naked racism, the bald-faced assertion that "America was once their country. They sense they are losing it. And they are right." These three short sentences, that end this sad tale of the demise of "traditional America's" dominance should stand as a monument to the way Barack Obama's Presidency has liberated us from Nixon-era "law and order" public discourse, a veiled way of talking about what was really on the minds of right-wing white folks - keeping the brown folk down, in the ghetto, and back in de facto segregation. The on-going social and cultural gains of African-Americans, culminating in Barack Obama's Presidency 40 years after Nixon won, in part, by creating a new vocabulary for racist public talk, is now over, and we should at least be celebratory enough to recognize that it is OK for racists in the limelight to speak openly.
Make no mistake. MSNBC will continue to feature Buchanan even though - or perhaps precisely because - he is honest enough to put his racist thoughts on paper (or over the 'net) for all the world to see. Unlike Peggy Noonan*, who misused the word "boorish" to describe President Obama, because she didn't want to use the word "uppity", Buchanan is right up front talking about how some white folk are just plain scared of the black boy in the White House who isn't a cook or a butler. Conservatives should follow Buchanan's lead and be unafraid to let the world know their dislike of Pres. Obama is rooted not in any supposed ideological radicalism he embodies, because such doesn't exist; but, rather, they dislike him precisely because he is the first African-American President. Period.
I do not mourn with Buchanan. I do celebrate the end of a too-long era when racists with a big audience couched their hatred in euphemisms. We no longer have to sit around and decode all sorts of words about "law and order", and "traditional values". We can use this column by Buchanan as a template for judging the honesty and integrity of conservative talk about Obama.
________________
*Isn't it fascinating that Noonan used to be a speechwriter, yet used the word "boorish" incorrectly?
In fact, the only thing about Buchanan's column that is surprising is the absence of code, the naked racism, the bald-faced assertion that "America was once their country. They sense they are losing it. And they are right." These three short sentences, that end this sad tale of the demise of "traditional America's" dominance should stand as a monument to the way Barack Obama's Presidency has liberated us from Nixon-era "law and order" public discourse, a veiled way of talking about what was really on the minds of right-wing white folks - keeping the brown folk down, in the ghetto, and back in de facto segregation. The on-going social and cultural gains of African-Americans, culminating in Barack Obama's Presidency 40 years after Nixon won, in part, by creating a new vocabulary for racist public talk, is now over, and we should at least be celebratory enough to recognize that it is OK for racists in the limelight to speak openly.
Make no mistake. MSNBC will continue to feature Buchanan even though - or perhaps precisely because - he is honest enough to put his racist thoughts on paper (or over the 'net) for all the world to see. Unlike Peggy Noonan*, who misused the word "boorish" to describe President Obama, because she didn't want to use the word "uppity", Buchanan is right up front talking about how some white folk are just plain scared of the black boy in the White House who isn't a cook or a butler. Conservatives should follow Buchanan's lead and be unafraid to let the world know their dislike of Pres. Obama is rooted not in any supposed ideological radicalism he embodies, because such doesn't exist; but, rather, they dislike him precisely because he is the first African-American President. Period.
I do not mourn with Buchanan. I do celebrate the end of a too-long era when racists with a big audience couched their hatred in euphemisms. We no longer have to sit around and decode all sorts of words about "law and order", and "traditional values". We can use this column by Buchanan as a template for judging the honesty and integrity of conservative talk about Obama.
________________
*Isn't it fascinating that Noonan used to be a speechwriter, yet used the word "boorish" incorrectly?
Monday, October 19, 2009
What Pluralism Is Not
In a fit of . . . I don't know . . . openness, maybe, I tried to begin, again, reading Jurgen Moltmann's God For a Secular Society: The Public Relevance of Theology, and was again struck by its many faults early on. I realize it's pretty bold to call out a major theologian as writing something that just doesn't quite cut it, but sometimes, you have to call it as you read it. On the very first page, I realized that I just couldn't do it. From p. 1, the preface, in the Fortress Press edition translated by Margaret Kohl:
I do not know if Moltmann is being coy here, or ignorant. I do so hope it is not the latter, because the definition he gives of "pluralism" is hardly my understanding of it. On the contrary, liberal pluralism accepts the diverse ways human beings go about the task of living out a fully human life; it also accepts the incommensurability and incompatibility of this variety, and accepts, with sadness, the reality of conflict that will arise because of these differences. The hope that liberal pluralism holds out is that these differences, and the ensuing conflict, can be settled via negotiation rather than violent confrontation.
By defining "pluralism" as restricting Christian theological reflection to a Christian ghetto, Moltmann may be reacting to the on-going marginalization of mainstream Christianity in Western Europe. His position, however, is just not tenable in more vibrantly religious places of the world, which make his apologia for the "public relevance of theology" absurd on its face, whether in a religiously diverse place like the United States, or robust Roman Catholic states such as Mexico (which, ironically, has an even greater constitutional stricture on the place of the church in public life than the US).
While I could be heartened by learning from a different perspective, I cannot move forward because Moltmann's position - that Christian theology needs to fight for relevance in the public sphere - is one I just don't take seriously. For my part, I really don't care that other scholars find theology a joke, or that most leaders don't listen to what the Church has to say on this or that issue. All that really matters is that the Church does say it. The rest, well, that's up to God.
If you begin your argument by spending a whole lot of intellectual energy attempting to prove to other people that what you have to say isn't nonsense, you've already lost. Just say it; if they don't like it, or laugh at it, well they laughed at Noah, they tried to kill Elijah, and we all know what happened to Jesus.
It might also be important, along the way, to not set up straw obstacles like the "pluralism" that Moltmann seems to have invented.
Remembrance of the crucified Christ makes [public theology] critical towards political religions and idolatries. It thinks critically about the religious and moral values of the societies in which it exists, and presents its reflections as a reasoned position. But it refuses to fall into the modern trap of pluralism, where it is supposed to be reduced to its particular sphere and limited to its own religious society. Because today these restrictions to one's own particular reserve in Western multi-religious society can be felt everywhere, and are actually welcomed by certain church leaders and theologians, I hope that these contribution may demonstrate and reinforce the public relevance of theology.[emphasis added]
I do not know if Moltmann is being coy here, or ignorant. I do so hope it is not the latter, because the definition he gives of "pluralism" is hardly my understanding of it. On the contrary, liberal pluralism accepts the diverse ways human beings go about the task of living out a fully human life; it also accepts the incommensurability and incompatibility of this variety, and accepts, with sadness, the reality of conflict that will arise because of these differences. The hope that liberal pluralism holds out is that these differences, and the ensuing conflict, can be settled via negotiation rather than violent confrontation.
By defining "pluralism" as restricting Christian theological reflection to a Christian ghetto, Moltmann may be reacting to the on-going marginalization of mainstream Christianity in Western Europe. His position, however, is just not tenable in more vibrantly religious places of the world, which make his apologia for the "public relevance of theology" absurd on its face, whether in a religiously diverse place like the United States, or robust Roman Catholic states such as Mexico (which, ironically, has an even greater constitutional stricture on the place of the church in public life than the US).
While I could be heartened by learning from a different perspective, I cannot move forward because Moltmann's position - that Christian theology needs to fight for relevance in the public sphere - is one I just don't take seriously. For my part, I really don't care that other scholars find theology a joke, or that most leaders don't listen to what the Church has to say on this or that issue. All that really matters is that the Church does say it. The rest, well, that's up to God.
If you begin your argument by spending a whole lot of intellectual energy attempting to prove to other people that what you have to say isn't nonsense, you've already lost. Just say it; if they don't like it, or laugh at it, well they laughed at Noah, they tried to kill Elijah, and we all know what happened to Jesus.
It might also be important, along the way, to not set up straw obstacles like the "pluralism" that Moltmann seems to have invented.
Music For Your Monday
As someone who took years of piano instruction, I can only sit in awe when I listen to Art Tatum. Somehow this blind lover of baseball and Pabst Blue Ribbon beer ran his thick fingers as light and fast over the keyboard as a feather. He never seemed to miss a downbeat, play off-key, or take the music out of whatever mood it was supposed to inhabit. While many seem content to dwell on his technical ability, he combined that with a sense both of rhythm and melody that was unmatched until Charlie Parker emerged in the post-war years.
Here he is doing Gershwin's "Someone to Watch Over Me"
Another standard, Rogers & Hart's "Isn't It Romantic"
One of my favorite songs of all time, "Smoke Gets In Your Eyes"
The nice thing about these clips is there is no "video" of him playing, so you can get lost in his playing.
Here he is doing Gershwin's "Someone to Watch Over Me"
Another standard, Rogers & Hart's "Isn't It Romantic"
One of my favorite songs of all time, "Smoke Gets In Your Eyes"
The nice thing about these clips is there is no "video" of him playing, so you can get lost in his playing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)